In our guide to casting with three coins we stopped at one changing line: read that line's statement, and you have your answer. Most casts are not so tidy. Two, three, even all six lines can come up as 6 or 9, and then the Book does something that no other oracle does: it hands you a second hexagram. This article is about that second figure and how to read the pair.
Old lines move
Recall that a throw of three coins gives one of four lines. 7 is young yang and 8 is young yin: stable, they stay as they are. 6 is old yin and 9 is old yang: these are lines at the end of their phase, about to turn into their opposite. The I Ching's whole philosophy is in that word "old". Yang at its height becomes yin; yin at its fullest becomes yang. The hexagram you cast is a situation; its old lines are the places where the situation is already changing.
So you draw the hexagram twice. The first, with the lines as thrown, is the primary hexagram (本卦, ben gua): where you are. Then you flip every old line to its opposite, 6 to a solid line and 9 to a broken one, and draw the result. That is the resulting hexagram (之卦 or 变卦): where the situation is tending. Lines that were young stay as they are.
A cast with no old lines has no second hexagram. The situation is stable; you read the primary and stop.
Which text to read
The hexagram texts were written for exactly this procedure, and the tradition has rules for which part applies. The most widely followed are those of the Song philosopher Zhu Xi (朱熹), who set them out in his primer on the Book:
- No changing lines: read the Judgement (卦辞) of the primary hexagram.
- One changing line: read that line's statement (爻辞) in the primary hexagram. This is the clearest case and the most common.
- Two changing lines: read both line statements; the upper of the two is the governing one.
- Three changing lines: read the Judgements of both hexagrams. The primary describes the situation, the resulting its outcome.
- Four changing lines: read the two lines of the resulting hexagram that did not change; the lower governs.
- Five changing lines: read the one unchanged line of the resulting hexagram.
- Six changing lines: for hexagrams 1 and 2, which have a special seventh text for this case (用九 and 用六), read that; for any other hexagram, read the Judgement of the resulting hexagram.
The logic is that a few moving lines are the story, and the primary hexagram is the setting; when most lines move, the few that stay still are the story, and the resulting hexagram is the setting.
Many modern readers use a simpler practice: read the Judgement and Image of the primary, then every changed line's statement in order from the bottom, then the Judgement of the resulting hexagram as the direction of travel. This is not wrong. It gives you more text and less guidance about which part to weigh, and for a first year of reading it is a reasonable way to learn the Book.
Two examples from the opening chapters
The first two hexagrams, 乾 (Heaven, all six lines yang) and 坤 (Earth, all six lines yin), are the Book's two poles, and their line texts are the most famous in it. They make clean examples because any changing line in them changes the whole shape.
乾 with the fifth line changing. The fifth line of 乾 is the best-known line in the I Ching: 飞龙在天, "the flying dragon is in the heavens; it is favourable to see the great person". It describes a thing at its height, in its proper place, with its powers fully used. Now flip that line. Five yang lines with a yin line in the fifth place give the upper trigram 离, Fire, over 乾, Heaven: hexagram 14, 大有, "Great Possession". The pair reads as a sentence: at the summit of your powers, the tendency is toward great holdings, and the Book follows 大有 with 谦, Modesty: what is held greatly must be held with humility. A reader with a question about a success would take both parts.
坤 with the first line changing. The first line of 坤 is 履霜,坚冰至: "treading on frost, the solid ice will come." It is a warning line: a small sign of what is on the way, noticed early. Flip it, and one yang line appears at the bottom of five yin lines: the lower trigram is now 震, Thunder, under 坤, Earth: hexagram 24, 复, "Return", the hexagram of the winter solstice, the first stirring of yang under the ground. So the pair says: what you have noticed is the beginning of a turn. Whether that is welcome depends on your question, which is why the question comes first.
Notice that in both cases the second hexagram is not an answer to be read instead of the first. It is the first hexagram's direction of movement. The primary is the noun; the resulting is the verb.
Reading the line itself
A line statement is short, often strange, and written for a position as much as a situation. It helps to know what the six positions mean to the tradition:
- The bottom line: beginnings, something not yet visible, "hidden".
- The second: the inner centre, the official, steady and well placed.
- The third: the top of the lower trigram, a place of transition and danger.
- The fourth: the bottom of the upper trigram, near power but not holding it; caution.
- The fifth: the ruler's place, the position of highest authority and good fortune.
- The top line: beyond the summit; excess, withdrawal, or the sage who has stepped aside.
Read your changing line's statement with its position in mind, and the oddest images start to make sense. The dragon of 乾 is hidden in line one, in the field in line two, in the heavens in line five, and "arrogant" and regretful in line six; it is the same dragon at six stages.
In the consultation
The I Ching consultation casts the six lines, marks the changing ones, draws the resulting hexagram beside the primary when there is one, and shows the texts of both. When you ask the consultant about a cast, say how many lines changed and which: the answer should be built on the lines, not on the hexagram's name.